Key Verse:
“For I have not hesitated to proclaim to you the whole will of God.” — Acts 20:27 (NIV)
Every pastor eventually faces the same question: What am I going to preach next Sunday?
For some, the answer comes from a carefully planned sermon series. Others prefer preaching consecutively through books of the Bible. Still others select passages based on the needs of the congregation, the church calendar, or whatever the Holy Spirit seems to be impressing upon them.
And then there are pastors who follow the lectionary.
If you grew up in a non-liturgical church, the word lectionary may sound suspiciously like something involving robes, candles, and a committee meeting in the fourth century. But the concept is actually quite simple. A lectionary is an organized schedule of Scripture readings assigned to particular Sundays and seasons of the Christian year.
The most widely used modern example is the Revised Common Lectionary, which follows a three-year cycle and generally provides readings from the Old Testament, Psalms, Epistles, and Gospels each Sunday.
For pastors who use it, the lectionary can be a tremendous blessing. For others, it can feel unnecessarily restrictive. And both perspectives have legitimate points worth considering.
So, should you preach from the lectionary?
Like most questions involving preaching methodology, the answer is more nuanced than a simple yes or no.
The Benefit of Preaching Beyond Your Preferences
One of the strongest arguments for using the lectionary is that it forces pastors to encounter passages they might otherwise avoid.
Let’s admit something. Every preacher has favorite portions of Scripture. Some love Paul’s letters. Others gravitate toward the Gospels. Some enjoy Old Testament narratives, while others prefer doctrinal passages that lend themselves to clearly structured sermons.
Left entirely to ourselves, we can spend years preaching the portions of Scripture we find most comfortable.
The lectionary interrupts that tendency.
It introduces passages we might not have selected and challenges us to wrestle with texts that don’t immediately suggest a three-point outline. It reminds us that the Bible is larger than our favorite themes, theological interests, and preaching habits.
A pastor who has spent twenty years preaching primarily from the New Testament may discover a renewed appreciation for the prophets. Another who gravitates toward doctrinal exposition may find himself spending more time with the Psalms.
That kind of exposure can be healthy for both preacher and congregation.
The Drawback of Fragmented Preaching
The greatest weakness of lectionary preaching, in my opinion, is the potential for fragmentation.
A pastor may preach from Isaiah one Sunday, Matthew the next, Romans the following week, and then return to the Old Testament. Each sermon may be biblically sound, but the congregation can struggle to understand how the individual passages fit within their larger literary and historical contexts.
This is especially problematic when pastors treat the assigned reading as an isolated passage rather than part of a larger biblical argument.
One of the great strengths of consecutive expository preaching is that the congregation follows the development of a biblical book. They see how Paul’s arguments unfold, how a Gospel writer presents the ministry of Jesus, or how an Old Testament narrative develops its theological themes.
The lectionary does not automatically provide that continuity.
Of course, this weakness can be addressed. A thoughtful pastor can explain the surrounding context, connect the readings to the larger biblical narrative, and occasionally extend a passage beyond the assigned verses. Still, maintaining continuity requires deliberate effort.
The Christian Calendar Becomes a Teaching Tool
Another significant benefit of the lectionary is its connection to the Christian year.
Advent, Christmas, Epiphany, Lent, Easter, Pentecost, and the ordinary seasons of the church calendar provide a recurring framework for teaching the major events and doctrines of the Christian faith.
For churches that have historically paid little attention to the Christian calendar beyond Christmas and Easter, this can be surprisingly enriching.
Advent invites the congregation to consider both Christ’s first coming and His promised return. Lent provides opportunities to reflect upon repentance, discipleship, and the suffering of Christ. Easter celebrates the resurrection, while Pentecost directs attention toward the Holy Spirit and the mission of the church.
The advantage is not merely tradition for tradition’s sake. It is the regular, intentional rehearsal of the central truths of Christianity.
A congregation that follows these rhythms year after year is repeatedly reminded of the great story of redemption.
And repetition, when done thoughtfully, is not necessarily a weakness. Sometimes it is exactly what discipleship requires.
The Danger of Becoming Predictable
There is, however, another side to that argument.
A rigid commitment to the church calendar can create its own kind of predictability. The congregation knows what is coming, and the pastor may begin approaching familiar seasons with less creativity than they deserve.
After several cycles, Advent sermons can start sounding remarkably similar. The same thing can happen with Lent and Easter.
There is also the danger of allowing the calendar to become more important than the actual needs of the congregation.
Suppose your church has just experienced a devastating tragedy. Perhaps a beloved member has died unexpectedly, or the congregation is struggling through a painful conflict. The assigned readings may address the situation beautifully. But what if they don’t?
A pastor must remember that he is a shepherd, not merely a reader of scheduled texts.
The lectionary should serve the ministry of the Word. It should never become an obstacle to it.
It Can Relieve the Weekly Pressure
Here is a benefit that working pastors will immediately appreciate: the lectionary answers the question of what to preach next.
That may sound insignificant until you’ve spent thirty years facing Monday morning with a blank page and a rapidly approaching Sunday.
The lectionary provides a preaching framework months or even years in advance. Pastors can study upcoming passages, plan worship services, coordinate with musicians, and develop sermon themes without having to start from scratch every week.
For bivocational pastors, smaller-church ministers, and those carrying heavy administrative or pastoral responsibilities, that structure can be especially valuable.
It doesn’t eliminate sermon preparation. You still have to study the passage, understand its context, develop the message, and apply it faithfully.
But it does eliminate one recurring decision.
And sometimes eliminating one decision makes room for better preparation.
The Lectionary Doesn’t Cover Everything
Here is another important limitation: following the lectionary for three years does not mean you have preached through the entire Bible.
The Revised Common Lectionary provides a broad selection of biblical texts, but it is still a selection. Some passages appear frequently, while others receive little or no attention. Entire chapters and significant portions of biblical books may be omitted from the Sunday readings.
This matters because Paul did not merely tell Timothy to preach the familiar or comfortable portions of Scripture. He charged him to preach the Word, and Paul himself testified that he had proclaimed the whole counsel of God (Acts 20:27).
A pastor who relies exclusively on the lectionary may discover that certain doctrines, ethical questions, and difficult passages receive insufficient attention. Consecutive exposition through biblical books can help correct that imbalance.
The lectionary is a valuable guide, but it is not a substitute for a comprehensive understanding of Scripture.
A Shared Experience with the Wider Church
One benefit that sometimes gets overlooked is the sense of connection the lectionary provides with Christians beyond our own congregations.
On any given Sunday, thousands of churches across denominational and geographical boundaries may be reading and preaching from the same passages. A small congregation in rural Kentucky may be studying the same Gospel text as a large congregation in Chicago or a church halfway around the world.
There is something encouraging about that.
Of course, sharing Scripture readings does not mean sharing every theological conviction. Churches using the Revised Common Lectionary represent a wide range of doctrinal positions, and pastors must continue to interpret and apply Scripture faithfully.
But the common readings can remind us that Christ’s church extends far beyond our particular congregation, denomination, or tradition.
For pastors who sometimes feel isolated in their work, that broader connection can be meaningful.
You Don’t Have to Choose One Method Forever
Perhaps the most practical approach is to recognize that the lectionary and consecutive expository preaching are not mutually exclusive.
A pastor might follow the lectionary during Advent and Easter while preaching consecutively through biblical books during other seasons. Another might use the lectionary as the foundation for Sunday morning worship while teaching through individual books during a midweek Bible study.
Some pastors use the lectionary for an entire year and then devote the following year to a carefully planned expository series. Others consult the readings each week without feeling obligated to follow them.
There is also considerable flexibility within the lectionary itself. With several readings assigned to most Sundays, the pastor has options regarding which passage to emphasize. During much of Ordinary Time, the Revised Common Lectionary even provides alternative Old Testament reading tracks, including one that follows biblical narratives in a more continuous fashion.
The important thing is to make intentional decisions rather than simply drifting from one Sunday to the next.
The Real Question Isn’t Which Calendar You Follow
I’ve known pastors who followed the lectionary faithfully and preached excellent biblical sermons. I’ve also known pastors who never consulted a lectionary but consistently provided their congregations with rich, systematic exposition of Scripture.
And, of course, neither method guarantees good preaching.
A pastor can follow the lectionary and produce shallow sermons. Another can preach verse by verse through Romans and somehow miss Paul’s central argument. The preaching method matters, but it cannot replace careful study, sound interpretation, prayerful preparation, and a genuine concern for the spiritual welfare of the congregation.
The ultimate question is not whether your sermon text came from a lectionary, a preaching calendar, or the next passage in a biblical book.
The question is whether you have faithfully explained and applied the Word of God.
A Final Word
Pastor, if you’ve never considered using the lectionary, it might be worth exploring. You may discover passages you have neglected, themes you have overlooked, and a helpful rhythm for organizing your preaching year.
If you already follow it, remember that the calendar is your servant, not your master. Don’t hesitate to step outside the assigned readings when the needs of your congregation or the demands of faithful biblical teaching warrant it.
And if you prefer consecutive exposition, keep doing it well. There is tremendous value in leading a congregation through the unfolding argument of a biblical book.
The church doesn’t need pastors who are loyal to a particular preaching system above everything else. It needs pastors who are loyal to Scripture.
Whether you follow the lectionary, preach consecutively through books of the Bible, or combine the two approaches, the goal remains unchanged: to proclaim God’s Word faithfully, clearly, and courageously.
The calendar may determine the passage. But Scripture must determine the message.
A Little Help for Lectionary Preachers
If you use the Revised Common Lectionary—or are thinking about giving it a try—LectionaryLink.com offers weekly sermon and worship resources designed to make preparation a little easier. Free resources include a sermon outline, opening prayer, and call to worship based on the week’s readings, with full manuscript sermons available to paid subscribers.
It’s one more tool to help busy pastors spend less time wondering where to begin and more time doing what matters most: faithfully preaching the Word.



